Monday, October 29, 2007

Graphology - What is it

Graphology is the study of writing - of using a tool to make marks on a surface for the purpose of conveying meaning via characters. There is a lot of skepticism about this study, and rightly so. In the past, graphology was used to reject job candidates. The final analysis is always subjective, and people should not use it to judge others. Graphology does capture some traits about people, and it is a way to observe.

It does make snese that the emotional state of the writer will show up in the text created, but it all depends on culture. In the past, handwriting was taught in school to increase readability of written records. People were all taught to write the same. In some countries, physical punishment was used to enforce this uniformity. In that case, one would learn more observing the signature than the body of a message.

The rest of graphology is just leveraging statistics from comparing thousands of handwirting samples that are associated with personality profiles. I have never seen this collection of samples and it may not exist. It would be great if someone put it on the web. The question remains - who created the personality profiles that went with each sample in the collection. It is still a subjective measurement, even if the profile was created by the person who created the handwriting sample.

Some of the physical traits looked for in graphology do make sense, in a way. For example, if a person uses all physical space on the page, cramming letters together, this says something about them. One could guess that they would do similar things with the management of other resources, such as speech, space and time usage.

Graphology will always be an art, not a science.

Miscellaneous Samples

toi be defined

Samples of Signatures

to be defined

Samples of Capital I

to be defined

Samples of t

to be defined

The Signature

There is a lot that can be learned from a signature. The character size, the placement of the signature - can all be interpreted.

In western writing conventions, the signature comes last, written on the lower part of the page. The normal convention is to write the signature approximately 2/3rds of the way accross the page horizontally. If the signature is not in that position, we should look for reasons.

If the signature is in the middle of the page horizontally, the writer wanted to present himself before the reader expected to see it. This could mean something. Perhaps the writer wanted the reader to see the signature as more than it is - a boosting of one's image.

If the signature is not legible, the writer doesn't care if you know who he is. He is making a mark to indicate the text is his own, but the mark is no different than when a dog marks his territory with a little bit of urine. It means "mine" and nothing more.

In western signature conventions, the individual name comes first, followed by the family name. Comparing the 2 names is important, it may give indications of how this individual relates to his family.

Sometimes there is some artistic flair in the signature. If a final character stroke loops back over the top of the family name - this means something. The family name has the strongest association with the father. A stroke above the family name indicates that the father provided protection to the family - or at least, that is how the writer percieves his father.

Capital I - Representing Self

They say that what separates man from the animals is the ability to model ourselves - to see ourselves in our imagination, and know that we are observing ourself.

The meaning of the word "I". Descartes said: I think, therefore, I am. He neeed to say only the first word - the rest of the statement is redundant.

The fact that we can write a mark on a page and know it represents us is also a fantastic model. In English, it is done with a single character. We know it is not a self-portrait, yet is represents the writer. We see ourselves write the marks, know ing that the marks represent us. We impose on the marks more of the meaning of what is is to be ourself. It's not just a symbol. It is a repository.

The statistical model indicates that the loops of the cursive letter 'I' have distinct meaning. There is a vertical loop, which is the main body, and there is baseline horizontal loop. The stats show that the vertical loop represent the relationship the writer has with their father, and the horizontal loop is the representation of the relationship with the mother.

A way to remember this relationship is to imagine the mother lying flat, giving birth, and the father is standing at the opening of the birth canal, waiting to recieve the child.

Is one loop longer or wider than the other? Do the loops intersect/overlap? This might mean something.

I once collected a sample which had a strange anomalie. At the extreme left of the horizontal loop, the lines crossed, making a small bubble. Since this was in the opposite direction of the text flow, I thought it represented something the the writers past. I interpreted the smallness of the bubble to mean it was in the distant past - in very early childhood. Since it was the horizontal loop, I assumed that the bubble represented a woman, a surogate mother perhaps. When I said this to the right, she was stunned. It was then she told me that she was adopted. The bubble represented her birth mother.

If the writer is printing, then this information could be absent. If the word "I" is written in a single stroke, there isn't much to interpret. If the letter 'I' is made with 3 strokes - 2 short horizontal strokes, with an interconnecting long vertical stroke, then the top stroke represents the father, and the lower stroke represents the mother (but the analogy is not as strong as it is with the cursive I).

Some writers use a lowercase 'i' to represent themself. The interpretation is direct. The writer does not see himself as large as the other individuals - not deserving a capitalization. It is a sign of low self-esteem, or of voluntairily taking a lower social ranking.